THE SUSTAINABILITY MYTH
Share
Fashion's Uncomfortable Truth
PERSPECTIVES / 004
SUSTAINABILITY · FASHION INDUSTRY · CREATIVE LEADERSHIP
By Christian Arkins
Originally published December 12, 2024 · Updated with industry research, August 2026
Sustainability has become one of fashion's most powerful marketing messages. But how much of it represents meaningful change?
In recent years, sustainability has become the fashion industry's favorite buzzword.
It appears across marketing campaigns, glossy advertising, corporate reports, and the communications of some of the world's most influential fashion brands.
Yet for those of us who have spent decades working behind the scenes in this industry, the contradiction is increasingly difficult to ignore.
Much of what is presented as sustainability remains disconnected from the way fashion actually operates.
The industry's largest players possess extraordinary resources, influence, and the ability to transform global supply chains. Yet the distance between environmental commitments and the realities of production remains substantial.
The problem is not that sustainability is impossible.
The problem is that too often, sustainability has become a story brands tell rather than a fundamental change in how they do business.
The Illusion of Progress
At the heart of the issue is the disconnect between what major brands claim and what they deliver.
Fashion's largest companies produce enormous volumes of clothing, contributing to environmental pressures through resource consumption, pollution, emissions, and waste.
At the same time, sustainability campaigns frequently celebrate capsule collections, recycled materials, and products described as environmentally conscious.
These initiatives may represent genuine improvements.
But when they account for only a small portion of a company's overall operations, they cannot automatically establish that the business itself is sustainable.
The question is not simply whether a brand has introduced a more responsible product.
The question is whether its overall environmental impact is actually decreasing.
McKinsey and the Business of Fashion's State of Fashion 2026 describes an industry facing a sustainability stalemate, with progress challenged by economic pressures and rising expectations.
The contradiction is difficult to overlook.
A brand may improve the environmental performance of an individual product while continuing to increase the total volume of products it manufactures.
Efficiency without accountability for scale can become another form of illusion.
The Business Model Contradiction
A critical problem lies in the economics of the industry.
Many major fashion businesses depend on high production volumes, rapid product turnover, and constant demand for newness.
These systems are designed to maximize commercial efficiency and profitability.
Meaningful sustainability, however, often requires significant investment.
Better materials. More responsible manufacturing. Fair labor practices. Improved traceability. Cleaner energy. Products designed to remain useful for longer.
Such changes may challenge established pricing structures, sourcing decisions, and short-term financial expectations.
This is where sustainability becomes more than a communications strategy.
It becomes a question of business leadership.
If a company's environmental commitments never challenge its existing operating model, how transformative can those commitments really be?
Sustainability cannot remain a marketing initiative while the business model continues unchanged.

Greenwashing and the Language of Responsibility
Greenwashing has become one of the industry's most troubling contradictions.
A limited collection made with recycled materials can create the impression of a broader environmental transformation.
A vague commitment to future sustainability goals can attract positive attention without demonstrating measurable progress today.
Even terminology such as conscious, responsible, or eco-friendly can become misleading when it is not supported by specific, verifiable evidence.
This does not mean that every initiative is meaningless.
Progress should be recognized.
But genuine progress must be distinguished from the appearance of progress.
Transparency requires more than attractive language.
It requires brands to explain what has changed, how those changes are measured, and what environmental challenges remain unresolved.
A sustainability claim should be supported by evidence, not simply by an appealing narrative.
The Problem With Producing More
One of the most uncomfortable questions facing fashion is also one of the simplest.
Can an industry built around continually increasing production become genuinely sustainable without reconsidering the scale of that production?
Textile Exchange's Materials Market Report 2026 reveals that global fiber production reached approximately 139 million tonnes in 2025, increasing from around 132 million tonnes in 2024.
The growth was driven predominantly by increased production of virgin fossil-based synthetic fibers.
These figures are important because they illustrate a fundamental tension.
Even as the industry discusses circularity and more responsible materials, global fiber production continues to expand.
The European Environment Agency has also documented increasing textile consumption within the European Union, alongside the environmental pressures associated with fast fashion.
This is not simply a question of which materials we use.
It is also a question of how much we produce, how long products remain in use, and what happens when they are discarded.
We cannot measure sustainability only by what goes into a garment. We must also consider the system that produces it.
Quality Is Not an Optional Luxury
The focus on product quality reveals another contradiction.
Fast fashion and mass production frequently prioritize affordability, speed, and rapid replacement.
The result can be garments with limited durability, both physically and emotionally.
High-quality products designed for long-term use offer a different approach.
Better construction, thoughtful material selection, repairability, and timeless design can help extend a garment's useful life.
Of course, a higher price or a luxury label does not automatically make a product sustainable.
Environmental impact must be evaluated across the product's life cycle.
But designing for longevity is an important part of the solution.
As a designer and creative director, I believe the responsibility begins long before a product reaches the consumer.
It begins with the decisions made during development.
What are we creating?
Why does it need to exist?
How should it function?
How long should it last?
And will it remain relevant beyond the immediate season?
These are creative questions as much as environmental ones.
Designing something worth keeping is fundamentally different from designing something intended to be replaced.
Recycling Is Not a Complete Solution
Recycling is frequently presented as one of fashion's most promising answers to its environmental challenges.
Take-back programs, recycled polyester, and circularity initiatives have become familiar components of sustainability communications.
Yet the practical limitations remain considerable.
According to Textile Exchange's 2026 research, less than one percent of global fiber production came from recycled pre- or post-consumer textiles in 2025.
Most recycled polyester continues to be produced from sources such as plastic bottles rather than discarded garments.
This distinction matters.
Recycled content is not necessarily the same as textile-to-textile circularity.
Complex fiber blends, collection systems, sorting technologies, processing costs, and product quality requirements continue to create barriers to large-scale recycling.
Synthetic materials can also contribute to microfiber and microplastic pollution during use and disposal.
Recycling has an important role to play.
But it cannot, by itself, resolve the consequences of continually increasing production and consumption.
Circularity should not become an excuse to avoid confronting overproduction.
The Responsibility of the Industry's Largest Players
What makes this situation particularly frustrating is that the industry's largest corporations possess the resources to drive meaningful change.
They have the purchasing power to influence suppliers, invest in technology, improve traceability, and support more responsible production systems.
Smaller independent designers and emerging brands often work with significantly fewer resources, yet some demonstrate how alternative approaches can be explored.
The responsibility of larger organizations should therefore be proportionate to their influence.
McKinsey's 2025 research into fashion manufacturing emissions identifies fabric production and treatment as a major opportunity for decarbonization.
Its analysis indicates that Tier 2 manufacturing typically accounts for 45 to 70 percent of a fashion brand's Scope 3 emissions, excluding use and end-of-life impacts.
This highlights the importance of addressing the realities of manufacturing rather than concentrating exclusively on consumer-facing initiatives.
Cleaner production, supplier partnerships, improved processes, and measurable emissions reductions require sustained investment.
They are rarely as visually compelling as a sustainability campaign.
But they are far more consequential.
The industry cannot continue placing the primary responsibility on consumers to purchase more responsibly while avoiding difficult questions about its own production decisions.
Responsibility must begin with those who design, manufacture, finance, and lead the system.
Beyond the Sustainability Report
Many fashion companies now publish detailed sustainability reports outlining targets, commitments, and progress.
Such reporting can improve accountability when supported by reliable data and transparent methodologies.
But ambitious promises are not the same as achieved results.
A credible sustainability strategy must demonstrate progress against measurable objectives.
It must acknowledge setbacks.
It must explain the environmental consequences of growth.
And it must distinguish long-term aspirations from verified accomplishments.
The question should never be how convincingly a brand can communicate its sustainability ambitions.
The question should be whether those ambitions are changing the way the company operates.
This requires honesty, even when the answers are uncomfortable.
Sustainability Requires Creative Leadership
The fashion industry has extraordinary creative talent.
Designers, product developers, material specialists, manufacturers, and business leaders possess the ability to rethink how products are conceived and brought to market.
But meaningful change requires sustainability to become part of the creative and commercial decision-making process.
Not an isolated department.
Not an annual report.
Not a campaign developed after the collection has already been produced.
It must influence the original brief, material choices, product architecture, manufacturing relationships, and long-term business strategy.
Creative leadership has a responsibility to challenge established assumptions.
To ask whether a product should exist before deciding how it should look.
To question unnecessary complexity.
To recognize that innovation does not always mean creating more.
Sometimes, it means creating less — but creating it better.
The most important design decision may be the decision not to produce something unnecessarily.

The Truth Behind the Promise
Real sustainability in fashion requires systemic change.
It requires confronting overproduction, investing in more responsible supply chains, improving labor conditions, extending product life, and measuring environmental performance with greater transparency.
It requires businesses to recognize that environmental responsibility cannot always be achieved without challenging established commercial priorities.
And it requires creative leaders to understand that design decisions have consequences far beyond aesthetics.
I have spent much of my career working within an industry capable of extraordinary imagination and innovation.
That is precisely why I believe we should demand more from it.
Fashion has the creativity, expertise, and influence to help develop better ways of operating.
What it needs is the willingness to move beyond the appearance of change.
Because sustainability is not a seasonal trend.
It is not a marketing position.
And it is certainly not a story that can be manufactured.
True sustainability cannot be achieved through half-measures or empty promises.
It requires action. And the clock is ticking.
CHRISTIAN ARKINS
Creative Director · Brand Builder · Design Leader
New York · Amsterdam · Global
christianarkins.com
Research & Further Reading
McKinsey & Company and The Business of Fashion
The State of Fashion 2026 — Industry outlook and sustainability challenges.
https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/retail/our-insights/state-of-fashion
McKinsey & Company
Sustainable Style: How Fashion Can Reduce Tier 2 Emissions — March 2025.
Textile Exchange
Materials Market Report 2026 — Global fiber production and recycling data.
https://dev.textileexchange.org/app/uploads/2026/09/2026-Materials-Market-Report.pdf
European Environment Agency
Circularity of the EU Textiles Value Chain in Numbers — Textile consumption and environmental pressures in Europe.
Ellen MacArthur Foundation
Scaling Circular Business Models: A Guide for Fashion Leaders — Research exploring how fashion companies can move beyond sustainability messaging and integrate circularity into core business strategies, including repair, resale, and extending product lifecycles.
https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/building-the-business-case/overview
Rethinking Business Models for a Thriving Fashion Industry — An examination of fashion's dependence on increasing production volumes and the opportunities for creating economic value while reducing resource consumption.
https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/fashion-business-models/overview